logo the cost of damage
about
services
cost of damage
materials
products
site map
contact
home




 

No Scratch Goes Unpunished.

Class A painted surfaces suffer from two preventable forms of damage: scratches and dents. 

Scratches

Scratches result from contact with a tool, ring, watch or component that can be seen and that must be repaired. The average industry cost to repair a 1cm scratch is $175.

Scratches are the most insidious damage and are generally not process related but the result of an associate dragging an air line over a fender or hitting a part with another. Because scratching is so difficult to pin down, covering affected parts prevents it. It’s important that the protection system used does not itself create damage by sliding and moving once installed.  For this reason, a good protection system will not allow rigid plastic to contact a Class A surface.

It is also important that the protectors remain in the proper, designed position. Doing this involves engineering attachment areas or ‘clips’ to reference to body panels in a consistent and easily installed manner.

Dents

Dents are caused by contact with tools, material handling systems and other parts. Dents result in extensive, and expensive, rework and can include replacement of sheet metal.

We’ve seen a steady reduction in the thickness of sheet metal to lower weight to meet CAFE standards. While this may be good for gas mileage, body panels are now thin enough to deflect with a push of the thumb. Training line associates to ‘be careful’ is wishful thinking at best. It no longer takes a hit from the Terminator to crush a fender—anyone can do it.

Dents can usually be traced back to a process problem. In one memorable instance, an associate repeatedly pressed a defective socket back on an air tool by pressing the socket against the fender because the fender was covered with a sewn vinyl protector so there would be no problem. He never looked under the protector but management did—200 vehicles later.  There was little rejoicing when the cause was found but we did receive an order for energy absorbing HardGuard products. Even with our protectors, it’s difficult to prevent damage from a swinging air tool so we now design systems that offer multiple levels of protection.

 

 

back to top